preview

Holmes Vs Clay

Decent Essays

There is a hero and a villain in almost every fiction piece. A protagonist and an antagonist. Each with their own set of unique characteristics that make them exceedingly different, yet they have to be somewhat alike to make the story engaging. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes and John Clay are perfect examples of this. Although they are vastly different characters one can not miss the obvious similarities between the pair. Holmes and Clay are both extremely intelligent, the best at what they do, and obtain alternating personalities. In “The Red-Headed League”, Sherlock Holmes is an unforgettable character and detective with many remarkable traits that help define him. One of these traits is his abnormal intelligence level which is shown multiple times throughout the short story. Some examples include his collection of observations on Jabez Wilson and how he was able to solve the case by just walking around a street corner. Watson says, “I trust that I am not more dense than my neighbors, but I was always oppressed with a sense of my own stupidity in my dealings with Sherlock Holmes.” (Pg.1181) This impressive intelligence level is what makes him unique and easily able to solve cases. Due to these high reasoning abilities he is also able to be the best at what he does. …show more content…

While John Clay, our antagonist, is portrayed to share all of these same qualities with Holmes. They take on these hero and villain characteristics to make them different characters yet they are still very much alike. Similarities between two characters, that are opposing each other, is common in many fictional pieces. Without this many of the famous good vs. evil personalities we know today would fail to exist. Holmes and Clay are just another dynamic duo that readers will find to be very similar and very

Get Access