Group 2 Writing assignment 3
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Wayne State University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
7320
Subject
Business
Date
May 12, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
5
Uploaded by CoachFieldTapir34 on coursehero.com
Group 2: Christina Evans, Liberty Hunter, Dean Klingensmith, Evan Lemak, Dasia Parks
Group Writing Assignment 3 - (Cost-Volume-Profit Analysis) Complete Ch 12 Cases (Review Questions 79, 80 & 81)
79. Harry Mendelson began his fraud investigation with great optimism. He was investigating a simple embezzlement from accounts receivables, in a small business with only one employee, and only the bookkeeper had ever had access to the Intuit Quickbooks accounting files. The bookkeeper was fired the day before Harry arrived. When Harry opened the Quickbooks system, he immediately
noticed all kinds of strange entries that made no sense at all. After several hours of carefully studying the cash and accounts receivables, he concluded that the Quickbooks records were of no help.
Next he discovered that there were no paper statements or deposit records for the company’s bank account. After obtaining the online access credentials for the
company’s bank account, he was able to log in and view bank statements for the last 12 months, but all deposits simply showed up as lump sums with no reference to which portions were made in cash or in checks from customers.
His client was a small insurance agency. Many clients of the agency made their payments at the agency’s front desk, sometimes with cash and sometimes by check. Other clients sent their checks by mail. The bookkeeper opened all the mail. The front desk kept a list of all incoming payments before passing the checks on to the bookkeeper, but the list was only maintained sporadically and was, therefore, not reliable.
The owner was certain that the bookkeeper had embezzled a lot of money, but Harry is wondering if he should withdraw from the engagement due to the lack of data needed to conduct a reasonable investigation. Required:
What do you think Harry should do? What can he do? Is any kind of reasonable investigation possible?
Although there is lack of data needed to conduct a reasonable investigation, Harry can attempt to estimate the loss of the company by using reasonable means available for taxing purposes. For instance, Harry can gather the estimated amount that the company collected from the front desk list and compare it to the bank statements. By doing this, he can see the difference between the totals and gain a better understanding of how much may have been embezzled. However, since the list is not reliable, Harry may have to use video surveillance in the office to help him estimate (if camera footage is available). When the company fired the bookkeeper without a complete investigation, they did not take into consideration that case building and expert testimony may also be required in addition to the fraud report. Since independent fraud investigators do not generally state that specific suspects are guilty of fraud, Harry would have to be very careful with how he expresses his opinion in his report. If the company would have
allowed the bookkeeper to continue to work, they may have been able to gather helpful evidence to build a case against them.
Evidence showing an apparent shortage in deposits of customer receipts is not possible without a reliable list of deposits or accurate journal entries. Without these two things, Harry can not reconcile the bank statements with the cash receipts records. The loss remains an apparent loss for the company, unless Harry can rule out various reasonable explanations with a reliable amount that the company was collecting from customers. With reliable amounts that the company has collected, Harry could rule out if
the money was deposited into the wrong account, if it was deposited late and appeared on the next month’s statement, if the cash receipts records are in error, or if the bookkeeper who made the deposits did not receive the full amount of cash. Without reliable information to go off of, the reverse proof process can not be complete. Harry cannot draw any conclusions as to whether the apparent loss is a real loss.
If, however, Harry decided to investigate, there would only be one lead in the investigation. Since the bookkeeper was the only one who had access to the Quickbooks system and opened up the mail, Harry’s report may include something like, “There was a series of irregular computerized journal entries made in the accounts receivables ledgers and corresponding shortages in the Cash account. The employee in
charge of the computerized journal entries was fired from the company before this investigation began and was not available for an interview. The owner states that only the former employee had access to the journals in question.” The wording in this report suggests that the former employee may have embezzled funds from collections on account by making irregular journal entries. However, the report cannot guarantee that the bookkeeper did so, nor can it definitively conclude that a fraud occurred. Since the bookkeeper had more than one role in the company, the investigation would be very difficult to investigate without reliable numbers or journal entries.
80. Janet Markleson ran a profitable used-car business until the business failed as a result of an embezzling financial manager. The officers of the company were as follows: Janet was the president and treasurer, and her husband (now her ex-
husband) was the secretary. All ownership equity in the business had been lost when the company’s financial manager cleaned out all the bank accounts, including one trust account whose balance was to be remitted to consignment customers. In all, the financial manager managed to run away with over $432,000 from those accounts. Rumors circulated that he had left the country.
The financial manager also cleaned out the company’s trust fund account that was being used to remit payroll taxes to the IRS and to state tax authorities. The loss in that account amounted to $74,221.54.
Janet hired a forensic accountant, whose final report clearly indicated the losses, although it only identified the financial manager as a suspect and not a guilty party. No guilty party was clearly identified in the report.
Janet’s husband, Mark Merkleson, never had had any involvement in the business. He worked as a salesman in a local department store, and after years of
hard work he had managed to save up enough money to make a down payment on his first house, which he had planned to share with his new wife and raise a family.
Janet was bitter. Despite the forensic report the police wouldn’t seek an arrest warrant. She was told that even if they did prosecute, it would be impossible to get the suspect extradited from another country. She learned that extraditions can be expensive, and that local authorities didn’t have the budget to even pay the plane fare required to repatriate criminals in extradition proceedings.
About a month after the business failed, Janet woke up one day to find that someone had filed a complaint with the state revenue office, saying that she had stolen the pay- roll trust fund due to the state. She heard from a friend that it was the financial manager who had filed the complaint.
She tried to tell the criminal investigators from the revenue department that the financial manager had stolen the money. She showed them the forensic accounting report, but they seemed unimpressed by it and advised her that she was a target of a criminal investigation.
A few months later things got much worse. Her ex-husband Mark called her, furious, and told her that the IRS had just frozen his bank account, one day before he was supposed to close on buying his first house. He was close to crying, because his real estate sales contract had a clause that required him to close on time or lose a $10,000 deposit he had used as part of the sales agreement. So he was going to lose both his deposit and dream house.
Required:
Is there anything Janet can do to help her ex-husband? Why was his bank account frozen? Would it help if the financial manager were arrested?
Janet could supply the forensic accountant’s report, which identifies the financial manager as a suspect. Janet or Mark should directly communicate with the IRS to clarify Mark's role in the business and explain that he was not involved in the financial misconduct or embezzlement. Janet should prepare to defend herself against any criminal allegations related to the missing payroll taxes. This might involve legal representation to protect her rights and present evidence of the embezzlement by the financial manager. Mark's bank account was likely frozen by the IRS due to issues related to taxes owed by
Janet's business. Since Janet was the president and treasurer of the company and was responsible for remitting payroll taxes to the IRS, the failure of the business to pay these
taxes likely caused IRS actions against both Janet and Mark. The freezing of Mark's
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Questions
Please no written by hand solutions
Lisa was a successful bartender at a casino in Blackhawk for 10 years. She never had any disciplinary actions and is a favorite with repeat customers. The casino owners have a difficult time hiring and retaining employees. As a result, they offer a $2,000 signing bonus to any new bartenders who stay for 6 months. Lisa asks for a "retention bonus" of $5,000, but the owners refuse. She is the only female bartender and all the new hires are male. When Lisa complains, she is fired.
QUESTION #13:
What cause(s) of action could Lisa bring against the casino?
QUESTION # 14:
Who is likely to win-Lisa or the casino? What elements are the easiest to prove? What elements are the hardest to prove?
QUESTION #15:
If Lisa tells customers why she was fired and to stop going to the casino, can the casino successfully sue Lisa for loss of business? Why or why not?
QUESTION # 16:
If you are the casino's attorney, what would you advise the casino to do to avoid…
arrow_forward
Title of the research: Reimagining Mathematics Education during the COVID-19 Pandemic; Journal Name: Brock Education Journal; Volume: 29; Issue: 2; Page Numbers: 42–46; Year: 2020; Author Name: Anjali Khirwadkar, Sheliza Ibrahim Khan, Joyce Mgombelo,
Snežana Obradović-Ratković, Wendy Ann Forbes.
Q.7 How can i Write the reference in APA style from the above information.
arrow_forward
Q. As an associate member of the institute of human resources, you have been invited to give a Presentation on employee benefits. Briefly outline your presentation under the following subheadings1. Justification for employee benefits2. statutory benefits and their importance3. Factors considered in benefit planning4. d)Effective administration of benefits
arrow_forward
Q.NO.4. (08)
Designing the Training
A focus group was held with five managers to find out what they wanted from the training and to assess their concerns about performance management. This was a useful process. The managers wanted to include training in how to deal with difficult people, which otherwise may not have been included in the program. Including this also assured managers that their views were important and had been considered in the program’s design.
The training would take place in-house and outside the normal workday. It was agreed that the most appropriate method was a two-hour workshop. The workshop would include various activities geared to develop the skills and knowledge of the participants:
Trainer-ledinteractive
Roleplay
Use of aspecially designed case study.
Small-group
By developing and delivering the session in-house, training materials specific to the new performance management system could be created, rather than relying on generic training materials. It was…
arrow_forward
The Registered Insurance Brokers Act of Ontario states, "An insurance broker means any person who for any
compensation, commission or other thing of value, with respect to persons or property in Ontario, deals directly with the
public...etc." Which one (1) of the following is EXEMPT from the provisions of the RIB Act?
OA) An individual who for compensation solicits or negotiates a contract of insurance directly with the public on
behalf of more than one insurer.
OB) Operations where risk management services and claims assistance only are provided.
OC) Organizations where consulting or advisory services with respect to insurance or reinsurance are provided.
OD) An individual who acts solely on behalf of one insurer or affiliated group of insurers and the Facility Association.
arrow_forward
Search for following information online:
a.WorldCom fraud
b.Background of the CEO, Bernie Ebbers
c.How WorldCom’s market capitalization grew to one of the largest firms in the US
d. Information on the trial and related court testimony that convicted Bernie Ebbers
e. The internal audit team’s role in discovering and reporting the fraud to the Board of Directors, and
f. The role WorldCom's Controller played in the fraud.
Question 1: Specify how would owning and operating a small family business, like WorldCom at a time in history with rapid development and growth, create potential temptations and opportunities to commit fraud?
Question 2: As an expert witness asked to testify whether the journal entries recording fictitious revenues were fraudulent, whether the journal entries that improperly capitalized operating expenses as assets on the balance sheet were fraudulent. What facts would be highlight and included in evidence to support the testimony as an expert witness?
Please…
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
BUSN 11 Introduction to Business Student Edition
Business
ISBN:9781337407137
Author:Kelly
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Essentials of Business Communication (MindTap Cou...
Business
ISBN:9781337386494
Author:Mary Ellen Guffey, Dana Loewy
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Accounting Information Systems (14th Edition)
Business
ISBN:9780134474021
Author:Marshall B. Romney, Paul J. Steinbart
Publisher:PEARSON
International Business: Competing in the Global M...
Business
ISBN:9781259929441
Author:Charles W. L. Hill Dr, G. Tomas M. Hult
Publisher:McGraw-Hill Education
Related Questions
- Please no written by hand solutions Lisa was a successful bartender at a casino in Blackhawk for 10 years. She never had any disciplinary actions and is a favorite with repeat customers. The casino owners have a difficult time hiring and retaining employees. As a result, they offer a $2,000 signing bonus to any new bartenders who stay for 6 months. Lisa asks for a "retention bonus" of $5,000, but the owners refuse. She is the only female bartender and all the new hires are male. When Lisa complains, she is fired. QUESTION #13: What cause(s) of action could Lisa bring against the casino? QUESTION # 14: Who is likely to win-Lisa or the casino? What elements are the easiest to prove? What elements are the hardest to prove? QUESTION #15: If Lisa tells customers why she was fired and to stop going to the casino, can the casino successfully sue Lisa for loss of business? Why or why not? QUESTION # 16: If you are the casino's attorney, what would you advise the casino to do to avoid…arrow_forwardTitle of the research: Reimagining Mathematics Education during the COVID-19 Pandemic; Journal Name: Brock Education Journal; Volume: 29; Issue: 2; Page Numbers: 42–46; Year: 2020; Author Name: Anjali Khirwadkar, Sheliza Ibrahim Khan, Joyce Mgombelo, Snežana Obradović-Ratković, Wendy Ann Forbes. Q.7 How can i Write the reference in APA style from the above information.arrow_forwardQ. As an associate member of the institute of human resources, you have been invited to give a Presentation on employee benefits. Briefly outline your presentation under the following subheadings1. Justification for employee benefits2. statutory benefits and their importance3. Factors considered in benefit planning4. d)Effective administration of benefitsarrow_forward
- Q.NO.4. (08) Designing the Training A focus group was held with five managers to find out what they wanted from the training and to assess their concerns about performance management. This was a useful process. The managers wanted to include training in how to deal with difficult people, which otherwise may not have been included in the program. Including this also assured managers that their views were important and had been considered in the program’s design. The training would take place in-house and outside the normal workday. It was agreed that the most appropriate method was a two-hour workshop. The workshop would include various activities geared to develop the skills and knowledge of the participants: Trainer-ledinteractive Roleplay Use of aspecially designed case study. Small-group By developing and delivering the session in-house, training materials specific to the new performance management system could be created, rather than relying on generic training materials. It was…arrow_forwardThe Registered Insurance Brokers Act of Ontario states, "An insurance broker means any person who for any compensation, commission or other thing of value, with respect to persons or property in Ontario, deals directly with the public...etc." Which one (1) of the following is EXEMPT from the provisions of the RIB Act? OA) An individual who for compensation solicits or negotiates a contract of insurance directly with the public on behalf of more than one insurer. OB) Operations where risk management services and claims assistance only are provided. OC) Organizations where consulting or advisory services with respect to insurance or reinsurance are provided. OD) An individual who acts solely on behalf of one insurer or affiliated group of insurers and the Facility Association.arrow_forwardSearch for following information online: a.WorldCom fraud b.Background of the CEO, Bernie Ebbers c.How WorldCom’s market capitalization grew to one of the largest firms in the US d. Information on the trial and related court testimony that convicted Bernie Ebbers e. The internal audit team’s role in discovering and reporting the fraud to the Board of Directors, and f. The role WorldCom's Controller played in the fraud. Question 1: Specify how would owning and operating a small family business, like WorldCom at a time in history with rapid development and growth, create potential temptations and opportunities to commit fraud? Question 2: As an expert witness asked to testify whether the journal entries recording fictitious revenues were fraudulent, whether the journal entries that improperly capitalized operating expenses as assets on the balance sheet were fraudulent. What facts would be highlight and included in evidence to support the testimony as an expert witness? Please…arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- BUSN 11 Introduction to Business Student EditionBusinessISBN:9781337407137Author:KellyPublisher:Cengage LearningEssentials of Business Communication (MindTap Cou...BusinessISBN:9781337386494Author:Mary Ellen Guffey, Dana LoewyPublisher:Cengage LearningAccounting Information Systems (14th Edition)BusinessISBN:9780134474021Author:Marshall B. Romney, Paul J. SteinbartPublisher:PEARSON
- International Business: Competing in the Global M...BusinessISBN:9781259929441Author:Charles W. L. Hill Dr, G. Tomas M. HultPublisher:McGraw-Hill Education
BUSN 11 Introduction to Business Student Edition
Business
ISBN:9781337407137
Author:Kelly
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Essentials of Business Communication (MindTap Cou...
Business
ISBN:9781337386494
Author:Mary Ellen Guffey, Dana Loewy
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Accounting Information Systems (14th Edition)
Business
ISBN:9780134474021
Author:Marshall B. Romney, Paul J. Steinbart
Publisher:PEARSON
International Business: Competing in the Global M...
Business
ISBN:9781259929441
Author:Charles W. L. Hill Dr, G. Tomas M. Hult
Publisher:McGraw-Hill Education